What's a girl to do?

We started going to a new church about a year ago and joined a small group over the summer.  It's been so great to have a greater sense of community and to see more familiar faces on Sunday.  And the awkward "new kid" phase is almost over! { I think. I hope. }

Anyway, every week a couple brings a snack.  And this week is our turn.

First thought: YES!

Second thought: What in the world do I bring?!?

As much as I'd like to bring an enormous spread / full meal, I don't want to come across as overly eager.  I will have to slightly restrain the Martha Stewart gene I inherited from Mom.  It's probably best not to scare them with plates, napkins, utensils and a coordinating cake stand. : )

So far, folks have brought sweets.  Some homemade, some store bought.  All good.

Here's what I've been contemplating...

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes from Our Best Bites

Pumpkin Whoopie Pies with Cream Cheese Filling from Dreamy Desserts

Cheesy Baked Artichoke Dip from Bon Appetit via Picky Cook

Sweet & Salty Caramel Snack Mix from Our Best Bites

Which of these would you want me to bring? Help! : )